Struggling with Authenticity: A Critical Investigation of Authentic Agency for Mental Health Philosophy
Summary
In contemporary mental health research, authenticity and mental health are positively
associated. Essentially, extant literature suggests that the more authentic you are the better your
mental health. This thesis, however, argues that there are likely no principled grounds for thinking
that people with mental health problems are less authentic than everyone else. While authenticity is
a basic psychological concern in the lived experiences of people with mental health problems, two
dominant views on how authentic agency is possible, the self-discovery and self-creation view,
associate authenticity with optimal psychological functioning, with agency par excellence, and with
ethically ideal behaviour. An authentic existence can only come about when the subject functions at
a certain level of excellence. But what is deemed optimal or excellent is merely an idealised reiteration of psychological normality that forms a normative standard of mental health. This thesis argues that these views reiterate and reinforce this standard through the concept of authenticity such that the lived experiences of some people with mental health problems are unfairly pathologised. Accordingly, to be sufficiently flexible and open to the lived experiences of people with mental health problems, we must rework the concept of authenticity without presuming a positive association between authenticity and mental health.
Collections
Related items
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
-
Interculturalisation in mental health care: a qualitative study on the perceptions of and experiences with interculturalisation of professionals in mental health care
Trienekens, S.J. (2009)This thesis investigates the perceptions of and experiences with interculturalisation of professionals working in mental health care organizations. Furthermore, the influence of factors from both internal and external ... -
Thriving with Dyslexia: Exploring the Impact of University Mental Health Support and Dyslexia-Related Strengths on the Mental Health of Dyslexic Students in Higher Education
Frieling, Jet (2024)Introduction: There is an increasing number of neurodivergent students in higher education (HE) including students with dyslexia. Dyslexic students report more anxiety and depressive symptoms than non-dyslexic students. ... -
Cross-country differences in the association between socio-economic status and adolescent mental health: The role of mental health policies and services
Hlubek, Nick (2022)The “social gradient in adolescent mental health” describes the association between higher socioeconomic status (SES) and better mental health in adolescents. This association varies across countries, and little is known ...