View Item 
        •   Utrecht University Student Theses Repository Home
        • UU Theses Repository
        • Theses
        • View Item
        •   Utrecht University Student Theses Repository Home
        • UU Theses Repository
        • Theses
        • View Item
        JavaScript is disabled for your browser. Some features of this site may not work without it.

        Browse

        All of UU Student Theses RepositoryBy Issue DateAuthorsTitlesSubjectsThis CollectionBy Issue DateAuthorsTitlesSubjects

        A Defence of Aristotle's Unity of the Virtues: An Aristotelian response to the pluralistic rejection of the unity of the virtues

        Thumbnail
        View/Open
        Thesis_TijsOoms_6470041PUBLICATION.docx (153.0Kb)
        Publication date
        2024
        Author
        Ooms, Tijs
        Metadata
        Show full item record
        Summary
        In Aristotle’s virtue ethics the virtues of character are unified through practical wisdom. A virtuous agent cannot possess one virtue without possessing them all, as each requires practical wisdom, which in turn requires all the virtues. Today, pluralists assert that our ends are distinct, incompatible and possibly conflicting. Robert Adams and Christine Swanton have developed virtue ethical theories with pluralistic foundations. As a result of these foundations, they reject the unity of the virtues as it is presented by Aristotle. They do so using four arguments. The virtues are modular. Practical wisdom is modular. Virtue is a threshold concept and the world is too complex and difficult for a full unity of the virtues to possibly obtain. In this thesis, I argue that Aristotle’s theory offers the tools for rejecting these arguments. The virtues should be defined as active and procedural processes of the soul, such that they and practical wisdom are not modular. This also means that viewing virtue as a threshold concept does not lead to a rejection of the unity of the virtues. Lastly, the complexity of and conflict in the world around us does not imply a disunity of the virtues. I end the thesis by giving a positive account of how we might unify the virtues by appealing to a model for their integration that is offered by Adams and Swanton.
        URI
        https://studenttheses.uu.nl/handle/20.500.12932/47095
        Collections
        • Theses

        Related items

        Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.

        • Authenticity: the virtue of an otherwise virtueless world - Existentialist authenticity as a contemporary replacement of classical virtue 

          Wyngaarden, D. van (2020)
          This thesis studies the relation between the concepts of authenticity, virtue and happiness. It aims at answering the question: Is Sartrean authenticity a contemporary version of Aristotelian virtue? In addition, it shows ...
        • The Healing Factor of Virtue in Medicine: Why physicians should apply virtue ethics to best fulfill their professional role 

          Wijck, N. van (2021)
          In the current health care systems the focus seems to be less and less on the moral aspect. The current dominant biomedical model of medicine holds that diseases should be defined according to the abnormal microphysiological ...
        • Reconsidering Virtue in the Anthropocene: A return to individual virtue in order to overcome the corruption of climate change. 

          Kahler, J.A. (2021)
          In this paper I explore the role of individual virtue within the Anthropocene. Authors like Stephen Gardiner and Dale Jamieson appeal to a return to individual character in order to overcome the moral corruption of climate ...
        Utrecht university logo