View Item 
        •   Utrecht University Student Theses Repository Home
        • UU Theses Repository
        • Theses
        • View Item
        •   Utrecht University Student Theses Repository Home
        • UU Theses Repository
        • Theses
        • View Item
        JavaScript is disabled for your browser. Some features of this site may not work without it.

        Browse

        All of UU Student Theses RepositoryBy Issue DateAuthorsTitlesSubjectsThis CollectionBy Issue DateAuthorsTitlesSubjects

        Navigating in Uncertainty: developing an evaluation approach for transformative innovation policies and identifying conditions for its institutionalisation

        Thumbnail
        View/Open
        Master's Thesis Sander van de Wijngaert.pdf (720.7Kb)
        Publication date
        2023
        Author
        Wijngaert, Sander van de
        Metadata
        Show full item record
        Summary
        Innovation policies are increasingly aimed at addressing grand societal challenges. These Transformative Innovation Policies (TIPs) aim to fundamentally change sociotechnical systems such as energy, transport and food. Because TIPs are generally one of many interventions aiming for transformative change and their impacts appear a long way upstream from their implementation, they pose a substantial evaluation challenge. Current evaluation frameworks are mostly focused on single measures with clear predefined goals and a focus on policy outputs rather than outcomes or final impact, making them unable to capture specific transformative-related evaluation challenges. This study acknowledges the government’s active role in steering transitions and set out to develop an evaluation approach suitable to the evaluation of TIPs and identify necessary conditions for the adoption of this approach by governments. In synthesising transition literature that attributes transition tasks to governments with policy evaluation literature, this research argues that these transition tasks should be adopted as policy objectives and therefore must be subject to evaluation. Moreover, it discusses that it is likely that tensions arise in policy evaluation practices as TIP evaluation asks for learning-based evaluations while policymakers are bound to traditional normative frameworks that favour accountability. Four consecutive analytical steps were conducted. This research analysed whether and how transition tasks were evaluated in TIP evaluation whereafter these observations were compared with expert perspectives on current evaluation practices to propose an approach that suits the evaluation of transition tasks. An evaluation approach is proposed that evaluates whether conditions are created to successfully execute transition tasks. To do so, the evaluation approach suggests a reflexive process through stakeholder inclusion that is based on a flexible Theory of Change. Discussing challenges in evaluating transition tasks with policy evaluation experts led to the identification of barriers to the adoption and implementation of the proposed approach. Internal government structures are in place that hold civil servants accountable for their actions rather than providing room for learning. Through an illustrative case study, this research finds that current barriers to successfully executing transition tasks can be resolved when the reflexive approach is implemented early in the policy process. Moreover, the case study identified favourable conditions for learning. Several recommendations are made to legitimise learning within governments in an accountability-dominated evaluation culture.
        URI
        https://studenttheses.uu.nl/handle/20.500.12932/44789
        Collections
        • Theses

        Related items

        Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.

        • Stakeholder involvement in the policy process of immigrant integration policies: Working together towards effective local immigrant integration policies in the Netherland 

          Beers, P.A.E. van (2019)
          Where the scientific and policy debates surrounding integration policies were before about the definition of integration, the focus has shifted to the effectiveness of integration policies and the way to prove the effectiveness ...
        • Provincial governments as policy entrepreneurs: an analysis of policy entrepreneurship strategies and challenges for policy implementation 

          Lebbing, Jasper (2024)
          In order to achieve climate mitigation goals, governments formulate strategic policies to facilitate the energy transition. In the Dutch planning context, local governments ultimately have planning authority as they set ...
        • Between Policy and Reality: An interpretive policy analysis of the Inclusive Education Policy of Namibia 

          Volleberg, I.M. (2020)
          In this research, Interpretive Policy Analysis (IPA) is applied to the Inclusive Education Policy (IEP) of Namibia. Following Yanow’s steps, first, three interpretive communities are identified: the government as creators ...
        Utrecht university logo