View Item 
        •   Utrecht University Student Theses Repository Home
        • UU Theses Repository
        • Theses
        • View Item
        •   Utrecht University Student Theses Repository Home
        • UU Theses Repository
        • Theses
        • View Item
        JavaScript is disabled for your browser. Some features of this site may not work without it.

        Browse

        All of UU Student Theses RepositoryBy Issue DateAuthorsTitlesSubjectsThis CollectionBy Issue DateAuthorsTitlesSubjects

        Virtue Ethics and Situationism: The Person-Situation Debate Examined

        Thumbnail
        View/Open
        Thesis Igitur.pdf (572.7Kb)
        Publication date
        2015
        Author
        Geest, M. van der
        Metadata
        Show full item record
        Summary
        Aristotle’s virtue ethics relies heavily on both a characterological moral psychology and the concept of practical wisdom. However, in recent years psychological experiments have led to debates on the influence of our character traits on our behavior, as well as on the possibility of practical wisdom as active deliberation. According to these experiments, we behave differently than expected on the basis of the Aristotelian view on character, and most of the cognitive processes that influence our behavior are substantially automatic and unreflective. Based on the results of these experiments, some philosophers, known as situationists, have argued that our behavior is influenced mostly by situational factors and not by our character. This debate between virtue ethicists on the one hand, and situationists on the other hand, is also known as the person-situation debate. My aim in this thesis is to examine the person-situation debate and explore the consequences of the psychological account of the situationists for virtue ethics. I will discuss three positions: the virtue ethical position, the situationists’ position, and a reconciliatory position. After discussing these three positions I will examine the consequences of the person-situation debate for virtue ethics.
        URI
        https://studenttheses.uu.nl/handle/20.500.12932/20327
        Collections
        • Theses
        Utrecht university logo